Home » Best Ice Cream Maker Consumer Reports – Detailed Buying Guide

Best Ice Cream Maker Consumer Reports – Detailed Buying Guide

Please Note – We get commissions for purchases made through links in this post.

Ice creams are delicious, but they are expensive as well. It is not possible to enjoy your favorite ice cream flavors from your favorite ice cream shop every day, but there is no need to. You can prepare delicious ice cream in the comfort of your home with an ice cream maker.

Not just ice creams, but you can make a wide range of frozen delights such as sorbets or frozen yogurts in an ice cream maker, which shows how useful this product can be. But which one to buy? Well, the answer to that question lies in the list of the 5 best ice cream maker consumer reports. Just take a look at the products below and make your pick.

5 Best Ice Cream Makers To Buy
1. Cuisinart ICE-30R Pure Indulgence Ice Cream Maker

Cuisinart ICE-30R Pure Indulgence Ice Cream Maker

Want to buy an ice cream maker? Check out this incredible model by Cuisinart, which doesn’t just prepare ice creams, but frozen yogurt too. Boasting a stylish and durable design, you can prepare your favorite ice creams for years without worrying about the machine’s health.

As far as preparing ice cream is concerned, then you just need to add the ingredients, turn the machine on, and wait for 25 minutes to get the raw materials turned into the sweet, frozen delight you’ve been craving.

The ice cream maker boasts a powerful motor, which helps you prepare up to 2-quart ice cream every day. The machine is made of BPA-free plastic, which is 100% safe for human consumption.

The company offers a 3-year warranty on the product against all manufacturing defects, so in case anything happens, you can get it repaired or replaced by the company.

2. Whynter ICM-201SB 2.1 Quart Upright Stainless-Steel Bowl Ice Cream Maker

Whynter ICM-201SB Ice Cream Maker

Take a look at this amazing ice cream maker, which has been built from high-quality stainless steel. The right unit for individuals who want to prepare up to 2 liters of ice cream in one go.

Just imagine yourself sitting in an air-conditioned room and enjoying your favorite ice cream that you prepared yourself, wouldn’t that be a great experience? We’re sure it would.

Once you are done preparing the ice cream, you can easily remove the stainless steel bowl attached and clean it The company has inducted the automatic motor inside it which gets off if the unit is longer in use.

If you want to view the settings or see any other important information like the time remaining to prepare a dessert, then you can see that on the LCD control attached to the top of the ice cream maker. As far as the safety or health of a user is concerned, the company has used CFC-free refrigerant.

3. Breville BCI600XL Smart Scoop Ice Cream Maker

Breville BCI600XL Smart Scoop Ice Cream Maker

If you are a frigophill and can go to any extent to satisfy your cravings, then the Breville BC1600XL Smart Scoop maker is the product you should go for. It is slightly on the pricey side, but the features justify the high cost, as they allow you to make delicious frozen delights in lesser period.

This ice cream maker has a self-refrigerating compressor that can keep the ice cream below -5 degrees Celsius for up to 3 hours. You can prepare 1.5 quarts of ice cream with this product in just 30 minutes.

This product consists of a motor, compressor, spatula, dasher, control panel, removable bowl, and cleaning brush. There is an LCD control panel given on the top of this unit from where you can adjust the settings and set the timer manually.

As a whole, the company has introduced all those features in this product, which are important from the user’s point of view and minimize the intervention. You have the option of selecting from 12 different hardness settings to prepare varied frozen items like Gelato, sorbet, and Yogurt.

Coming to the drawback of this unit, it is a bit expensive and the ingredients start to freeze after an hour or two.

4. Cuisinart ICE-70 Electronic Ice Cream Maker

Cuisinart ICE-70 Electronic Ice Cream Maker

Cuisinart is known for its innovative products and this ice cream maker is no different. The company has been manufacturing these machines since the start. Cuisinart ICE-70 is one of the latest models of ice cream makers.

You can make up to 2 quarts of ice cream in a single batch. You will find an LCD with an easy-to-operate control panel featured on the front. You can easily read the readings on the panel with the help of the LCD.

Multiple settings are available for selecting gelato, ice cream, and sorbet. The overall processing and paddle speed are quite impressive. You don’t need to worry about turning this ice cream maker off once your frozen delights are prepared, as there is an auto turn-off feature provided along with the timer that you can easily configure as per your needs.

It features an integrated measuring cup and ingredient spout to measure the ingredients properly. You will get a free recipe book with this ice cream maker. The only drawback noticed in this model is that the setup process is difficult for those trying for the first time.

5. Nostalgia Electric Bucket Ice Cream Maker

Nostalgia Electric Bucket Ice Cream Maker

This model will remind you of traditional ice cream makers in which you simply need to add Nostalgia ice cream mixes like Vanilla, Chocolate, or strawberry into the Aluminum canister and add a layer of ice and salt.

After churning it for 20-30 minutes, you can enjoy delicious ice cream at home. You can prepare up to 6 quarts of ice cream, gelato, or frozen yogurt in one batch with the Aluminum canister.

The powerful electric motor does the churning part, so you don’t have to do it manually. Its handles make it easy to carry products while the easy-clean bucket offers easy cleanup.

You can view the ice cream flavor and freezer storage easily, courtesy of the transparent lid provided on the top of this ice cream maker. The company has provided the recipe book inside the packing to try delicious creations at home.

How To Choose The Best Ice Cream Maker

If you want to be sure you are buying the best ice cream maker that actually meets your needs; there are a number of criteria you need to consider before making a final decision.

The Capacity And Quality Of The Tank

Whether you decide to opt for a cold accumulator ice cream maker or an ice cream maker, you must necessarily choose a model whose capacity corresponds to your needs.

Assuming that a liter of ice cream can be enough for 3 or 6 people at most, you have to make a choice according to your family size or simply take into account your consumption habits. On the market, the capacity of ice cream machines generally varies between 1 and 3 liters.

Some models have two or more tanks. You can therefore turn to these if you have great needs. The material construction used for the tank is also important. It is advisable to choose models whose bowl is made of stainless steel or aluminum. They are more durable, resistant, and easy to clean.

Device Size

Here is another important criterion not to be overlooked if you really want to choose the best ice cream maker: the size. In general, self-contained ice cream makers are more cumbersome than cold-storage ice cream makers.

So, you need to consider how much space you have for storage and storage before deciding. It is also important to pay attention to the size of the cooling bowl if you have to choose a classic ice cream maker. Be sure to choose a model that can fit in your freezer without worry.

Power, Cooling Time, And Preparation Time

The power of the best cold storage ice cream makers generally varies between 12 and 100 watts. Regarding the cooling time of the tank, it can take between 8 to 24 hours depending on the model.

If it is an ice turbine, bet at least on a device with a power of 120 watts. Remember the cooling time of self-cooling ice cream makers largely depends on the power of their compressor. The larger it is, the shorter the duration.

Preparation time varies from model to model. But be aware that it often fluctuates between 20 to 45 minutes and largely depends on the power of the turbine.

Features, Options, And Accessories

If you really want to buy the best ice cream maker, you should choose a model with a timer system. Normally, most models sold on the market have them, but it is always good to check.

As an option, you may prefer an ice cream maker that incorporates an automatic shut-off function, sound signal, keeps cold (10 minutes to 2 hours), pre-recorded programs, a pause button, and a display screen.

To make life easier for users, some manufacturers provide accessories such as an additional tank, an ice cream scoop, a measuring cup, a recipe booklet, etc. Their presence is a plus and not a sign of poor quality.

Summing Up

The best ice cream maker will save you from paying tens of dollars in an ice cream parlor. Moreover, you won’t just be able to prepare ice creams, but frozen yogurt and sorbets as well. So, don’t delay your decision now and buy an ice cream maker after going through the best ice cream maker consumer reports and enjoying ice cream throughout the year.